Mary Sue #4 takes the meta-narrative of fanfiction to an entirely new level as we explore the consequences of writer-character relationships. In this issue, words truly do hurt more than any physical villain could. After an emotionally charged fight drives a massive wedge between Jessica and Cassie, the stakes have never been higher for our protagonist. As Jessica disappears back into the mysterious Mary Sue world, Cassie is left reeling, forced to make a choice that will change her dynamic forever.
The series, published by BOOM! Studios, continues to demonstrate the creative prowess of its team. Meghan Fitzmartin’s script captures the raw, pensive energy of the fanfiction community while Lisa Sterle’s illustrations bring a vibrant and expressive life to every panel. This specific issue builds on the tension of previous chapters, making it a standout entry in the five-issue limited series.
What to Expect in Mary Sue #4
What readers will find in Mary Sue #4 is a deep dive into the psychological toll of creativity. Cassie is desperate enough to team up with her former best friend, Bennett, to make amends with Jessica. However, the path to reconciliation is anything but simple. To reach Jessica, they must find a way into a fanfic, and the only way to do that is by writing one. Specifically, they have to write fanfic about each other to bridge the gap between reality and the Mary Sue World.
This issue highlights the full creative team behind the book:
- Script by: Meghan Fitzmartin
- Illustrated by: Lisa Sterle
- Colored by: Dearbhla Kelly and Heather Breckel
- Letters by: Jodie Troutman
- Editor: Elizabeth Brei
Transitioning from the real world to the fictional plane allows the art team to showcase different styles. Meanwhile, the dialogue remains sharp, as Cassie deals with the “chaotic evil” pirate version of herself that Bennett has unleashed. It is a nightmare that keeps getting worse, forcing Cassie to confront her own insecurities as a writer and a friend.
Navigating the Mary Sue World
A major highlight of Mary Sue #4 is the first proper introduction to the Mary Sue World. This isn’t just a abstract concept; it is a physical location with distinct neighborhoods. As Cassie and Bennett travel through this realm, we see glimpses of diverse fandom-inspired locales like “The Shire,” “Baker St,” “Neo Tokyo,” and “Deep Space.” This world is where characters live, work, and play when they aren’t actively being written by their creators.
The world-building here is exceptional, reflecting the “Riverview” fanfiction roots that have been teased since the first issue. In addition, the meta-commentary on “one-shot lemons” and “hundred-chapter slow burns” adds a layer of humor that balances the heavier emotional beats. For those who enjoy looking at comic book covers, the variant art for this issue perfectly captures the “Mary Sue World” aesthetic, blending different genre tropes into a single, cohesive vision.
Furthermore, the interaction between London (the pirate Mary Sue) and Cassie provides a hilarious yet biting critique of how writers often project their desires onto their characters. London’s demand for “meaningful sex” or a “slow burn” relationship is a direct challenge to Cassie’s perception of the real world, where everyone always leaves. This conflict pushes the narrative forward, leading to a cliffhanger that sets up a massive finale.
In conclusion, Mary Sue #4 is a brilliant exploration of friendship, hurt, and the healing power of storytelling. By taking us into the heart of the Mary Sue World, Fitzmartin and Sterle have created a story that is both a love letter to and a critique of fan culture. If you are looking for a book that understands the complexities of being a fan and a creator, this is a must-read.
💬 Ending the Post
What did you think of this issue? Join the conversation on X and tag us @comicbookaddt!
Follow us for more updates:
